There are signs that the answer is not necessarily “no one.” The 2024 study from Kalikot found that younger generations were not uniformly rejecting shamanic traditions. Instead, contemporary forms of shamanism were emerging alongside modern therapeutic approaches, suggesting that some practices can change rather than simply disappear.
Urban Nepal also offers a more complicated picture. Traditional healing practices have not vanished simply because people have moved to cities. A 2025 study of Dyo-mā, female faith healers in Kathmandu Valley, found that traditional spiritual and healing practices continue to have a place even within an urban environment, despite the influence of modern medicine.
The challenge, then, may be less about choosing between a hospital and a healer than about deciding which elements of traditional knowledge are worth documenting, preserving and studying.
There is also a distinction between preserving knowledge and endorsing every traditional treatment. Practices that carry potential health risks should not be protected from scrutiny simply because they are old. But dismissing an entire body of cultural knowledge can create another kind of loss—especially when that knowledge has never been properly documented.
For traditional healing to survive as a cultural heritage, younger generations may need opportunities to encounter it differently. Documentation, community archives, research into medicinal knowledge, cultural education and responsible intergenerational teaching could help preserve practices that might otherwise disappear with their last practitioners.
Nepal's traditional healers have historically stood at the intersection of health, spirituality and community life. Modernization has not erased that role overnight. Instead, migration, education, urbanization and changing ideas about healthcare are gradually weakening the system through which the knowledge is passed on.
The future of Nepal's shamans may therefore depend not on stopping modernization, but on whether the country can modernize without allowing valuable cultural knowledge to vanish undocumented.